Difference between revisions of "2023 AIME II Problems/Problem 15"

Revision as of 17:00, 29 December 2024

Problem

For each positive integer $n$ let $a_n$ be the least positive integer multiple of $23$ such that $a_n \equiv 1 \pmod{2^n}.$ Find the number of positive integers $n$ less than or equal to $1000$ that satisfy $a_n = a_{n+1}.$

Solution 1

Denote $a_n = 23 b_n$ . Thus, for each $n$ , we need to find smallest positive integer $k_n$ , such that $23 b_n = 2^n k_n + 1 .$

Thus, we need to find smallest $k_n$ , such that $2^n k_n \equiv - 1 \pmod{23} .$

Now, we find the smallest $m$ , such that $2^m \equiv 1 \pmod{23}$ . By Fermat's Theorem, we must have $m | \phi \left( 23 \right)$ . That is, $m | 22$ . We find $m = 11$ .

Therefore, for each $n$ , we need to find smallest $k_n$ , such that $2^{{\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right)} k_n \equiv - 1 \pmod{23} .$

We have the following results:

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 0$, then $k_n = 22$ and $b_n = 1$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 1$, then $k_n = 11$ and $b_n = 1$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 2$, then $k_n = 17$ and $b_n = 3$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 3$, then $k_n = 20$ and $b_n = 7$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 4$, then $k_n = 10$ and $b_n = 7$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 5$, then $k_n = 5$ and $b_n = 7$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 6$, then $k_n = 14$ and $b_n = 39$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 7$, then $k_n = 7$ and $b_n = 39$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 8$, then $k_n = 15$ and $b_n = 167$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 9$, then $k_n = 19$ and $b_n = 423$.

If ${\rm Rem} \left( n , 11 \right) = 10$, then $k_n = 21$ and $b_n = 935$.

Therefore, in each cycle, $n \in \left\{ 11 l , 11l + 1 , \cdots , 11l + 10 \right\}$ , we have $n = 11l$ , $11l + 3$ , $11l + 4$ , $11l + 6$ , such that $b_n = b_{n+1}$ . That is, $a_n = a_{n+1}$ . At the boundary of two consecutive cycles, $b_{11L + 10} \neq b_{11 \left(l + 1 \right)}$ .

We have $1000 = 90 \cdot 11 + 10$ . Therefore, the number of feasible $n$ is $91 \cdot 4 - 1 = \boxed{\textbf{(363) }}$ .

~Steven Chen (Professor Chen Education Palace, www.professorchenedu.com)

Solution 2

Observe that if $a_{n-1} - 1$ is divisible by $2^n$ , $a_n = a_{n-1}$ . If not, $a_n = a_{n-1} + 23 \cdot 2^{n-1}$ .

This encourages us to let $b_n = \frac{a_n - 1}{2^n}$ . Rewriting the above equations, we have $b_n = \begin{cases} \frac{b_{n-1}}{2} & \text{if } 2 \text{ } \vert \text{ } b_{n-1} \\ \frac{b_{n-1}+23}{2} &\text{if } 2 \not\vert \text{ } b_{n-1} \end{cases}$ The first few values of $b_n$ are $11, 17, 20, 10, 5, 14, 7, 15, 19, 21,$ and $22$ . We notice that $b_{12} = b_1 = 11$ , and thus the sequence is periodic with period $11$ .

Note that $a_n = a_{n+1}$ if and only if $b_n$ is even. This occurs when $n$ is congruent to $0, 3, 4$ or $6$ mod $11$ , giving four solutions for each period.

From $1$ to $1001$ (which is $91 \times 11$ ), there are $91 \times 4 = 364$ values of $n$ . We subtract $1$ from the total since $1001$ satisfies the criteria but is greater than $1000$ to get a final answer of $\fbox{363}$ . ~Bxiao31415

(small changes by bobjoebilly and IraeVid13)

Solution 3 (Similar to solution 2 but more explanation)

Let $a_n = 23b_n$ . Note that if $23 b_{n+1} \equiv 1 \pmod{2^{n+1}}$ Then $23 b_{n+1} \equiv 1 \pmod{2^{n}}$ Also $23 b_n \equiv 1 \pmod{2^n}$ Therefore $b_n \equiv b_{n+1} \equiv 23^{-1} \pmod{2^n}$ Then $b_{n+1} \equiv b_n, b_n + 2^n \pmod{2^{n+1}}$ So $b_{n+1} = b_n, b_n + 2^n$ Since $1 \le b_n \le 2^n$ and $1 \le b_{n+1} \le 2^{n+1}$ as $a_n$ is the _least_ positive integer multiple of 23.

Now suppose $b_{n+1} = b_n$ . Define $q_n$ to be the quotient of $23b_n$ divided by $2^n$ . Then $$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg) 23b_n = 2^n q_n + 1 \text{ and } 23b_{n+1} = 23b_n = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 = 2^n q_n + 1 \implies q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n}{2} $. Furthermore if quotient$ q_n $is even then <cmath> 23b_n = 2^n q_n +1 = 2^{n+1} \frac{q_n}{2} +1 </cmath> Therefore$ b_{n+1} = b_n $if and only if$ q_n $is even. And, if this is true, then$ q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n}{2} $. Next, if$ q_n $is odd, we must have$ b_{n+1} = b_n + 2^n $. Solving for$ q_{n+1} $, we have <cmath> 23b_{n+1} = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 \implies 23b_n + 23 \cdot 2^n = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 \implies 2^n q_n + 1 + 23 = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 \implies q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n + 1}{2} + 11 </cmath> Therefore, if$ q_n $is odd,$ q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n + 1}{2} + 11 $. In sum, our recursion is <cmath> q_n = \begin{cases} \frac{q_{n-1}}{2} & \text{if } 2 \text{ } \vert \text{ } q_{n-1} \\ \frac{q_{n-1}+1}{2} + 11 &\text{if } 2 \not\vert \text{ } q_{n-1} \end{cases} </cmath> Finally, let us list out$ q_n $to find a pattern. Because$ a_1 = 23 $,$ q_1 = 11 $. Through our recursion, we continue like so: <cmath> q_1 = 11, q_2 = 17, q_2 = 20, q_3 = 10, q_4 = 5, q_6 = 14, q_7 = 7, q_8 = 15, q_9 = 19, q_10 = 21, q_11 = 22, q_12 = 11, \dots </cmath> Therefore$ q_n $repeats with cycle length$ 11 $. Since$ a_{n+1} = a_n $if and only iff$ q_n $is even, in each cycle, we have 4 satisfactory values of$ n $. There are$ \frac{1000 - 10}{11} = 90 $complete cycles. There are 3 extra values in the last incomplete cycle. Therefore we obtain$ 90 \cdot 4 + 3 = \fbox{363}$.

== Solution 4 (Binary Interpretation, Computer Scientists' Playground) ==

We first check that$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)\gcd(23, 2^n) = 1 $hence we are always seeking a unique modular inverse of$ 23 $,$ b_n $, such that$ a_n \equiv 23b_n \equiv 1 \mod{2^n}$.

Now that we know that$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)b_n $is unique, we proceed to recast this problem in binary. This is convenient because$ x \mod{2^n} $is simply the last$ n $-bits of$ x $in binary, and if$ x \equiv 1 \mod{2^n} $, it means that of the last$ n $bits of$ x $, only the rightmost bit (henceforth$ 0 $th bit) is$ 1$.

Also, multiplication in binary can be thought of as adding shifted copies of the multiplicand. For example:

<cmath> \begin{align} 10111_2 \times 1011_2 &= 10111_2 \times (1000_2 + 10_2 + 1_2) \\

             &= 10111000_2 + 101110_2 + 10111_2 \\
             &= 11111101_2

\end{align} </cmath>

Now note$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)23 = 10111_2 $, and recall that our objective is to progressively zero out the$ n $leftmost bits of$ a_n = 10111_2 \times b_n $except for the$ 0$th bit.

Write$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)b_n = \underline{c_{n-1}\cdots c_2c_1c_0}_2 $, we note that$ c_0 $uniquely defines the$ 0 $th bit of$ a_n $, and once we determine$ c_0 $,$ c_1 $uniquely determines the$ 1 $st bit of$ a_n$, so on and so forth.

For example,$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)c_0 = 1 $satisfies$ a_1 \equiv10111_2 \times 1_2 \equiv 1 \mod{10_2} $Next, we note that the second bit of$ a_1 $is$ 1 $, so we must also have$ c_1 = 1$in order to zero it out, giving

<cmath>a_2 \equiv 10111_2 \times 11_2 \equiv 101110_2 + a_1 \equiv 1000101_2 \equiv 01_2 \mod{100_2}</cmath>$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)a_{n+1} = a_{n} $happens precisely when$ c_n = 0 $. In fact we can see this in action by working out$ a_3 $. Note that$ a_2 $has 1 on the$ 2 $nd bit, so we must choose$ c_2 = 1$. This gives

<cmath>a_3 \equiv 10111_2 \times 111_2 \equiv 1011100_2 + a_2 \equiv 10100001_2 \equiv 001_2 \mod{1000_2}</cmath>

Note that since the$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)3 $rd and$ 4 $th bit are$ 0 $,$ c_3 = c_4 = 0 $, and this gives$ a_3 = a_4 = a_5$.

It may seem that this process will take forever, but note that$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)23 = 10111_2 $has$ 4 $bits behind the leading digit, and in the worst case, the leading digits of$ a_n $will have a cycle length of at most$ 16 $. In fact, we find that the cycle length is$ 11 $, and in the process found that$ a_3 = a_4 = a_5 $,$ a_6 = a_7 $, and$ a_{11} = a_{12}$.

Since we have$ (Error compiling LaTeX. Unknown error_msg)90 $complete cycles of length$ 11 $, and the last partial cycle yields$ a_{993} = a_{994} = a_{995} $and$ a_{996} = a_{997} $, we have a total of$ 90 \times 4 + 3 = \boxed{363} $values of$ n \le 1000 $such that$ a_n = a_{n+1}$

~ cocoa @ https://www.corgillogical.com

Video Solution

https://youtu.be/ujP-V170vvI

~MathProblemSolvingSkills.com

@@ Line 76: / Line 76: @@
 (small changes by bobjoebilly and [[User:Iraevid13|IraeVid13]])
-== Solution 3 (Binary Interpretation, Computer Scientists' Playground) ==
+== Solution 3 (Similar to solution 2 but more explanation) ==
+Let <math>a_n = 23b_n</math>. Note that if
+<cmath> 23 b_{n+1} \equiv 1 \pmod{2^{n+1}} </cmath>
+Then
+<cmath> 23 b_{n+1} \equiv 1 \pmod{2^{n}} </cmath>
+Also
+<cmath> 23 b_n \equiv 1 \pmod{2^n} </cmath>
+Therefore
+<cmath> b_n \equiv b_{n+1} \equiv 23^{-1} \pmod{2^n} </cmath>
+Then
+<cmath> b_{n+1} \equiv b_n, b_n + 2^n \pmod{2^{n+1}} </cmath>
+So
+<cmath> b_{n+1} = b_n, b_n + 2^n </cmath>
+Since <math>1 \le b_n \le 2^n</math> and <math>1 \le b_{n+1} \le 2^{n+1}</math> as <math>a_n</math> is the _least_ positive integer multiple of 23.
-We first check that <math>\gcd(23, 2^n) = 1</math> hence we are always seeking a unique modular inverse of <math>23</math>, <math>b_n</math>, such that <math>a_n \equiv 23b_n \equiv 1 \mod{2^n}</math>.
+Now suppose <math>b_{n+1} = b_n</math>. Define <math>q_n</math> to be the quotient of <math>23b_n</math> divided by <math>2^n</math>. Then
+<math></math> 23b_n = 2^n q_n + 1 \text{ and } 23b_{n+1} = 23b_n = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 = 2^n q_n + 1 \implies q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n}{2}<math>.
+Furthermore if quotient </math>q_n<math> is even then
+<cmath> 23b_n = 2^n q_n +1 = 2^{n+1} \frac{q_n}{2} +1 </cmath>
+Therefore </math>b_{n+1} = b_n<math> if and only if </math>q_n<math> is even. And, if this is true, then </math>q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n}{2}<math>. Next, if </math>q_n<math> is odd, we must have </math>b_{n+1} = b_n + 2^n<math>. Solving for </math>q_{n+1}<math>, we have
+<cmath> 23b_{n+1} = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 \implies 23b_n + 23 \cdot 2^n = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 \implies 2^n q_n + 1 + 23 = 2^{n+1} q_{n+1} + 1 \implies q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n + 1}{2} + 11 </cmath>
+Therefore, if </math>q_n<math> is odd, </math>q_{n+1} = \frac{q_n + 1}{2} + 11<math>. In sum, our recursion is
+<cmath>  q_n = \begin{cases} \frac{q_{n-1}}{2} & \text{if } 2 \text{ } \vert \text{ } q_{n-1} \\ \frac{q_{n-1}+1}{2} + 11 &\text{if } 2 \not\vert \text{ } q_{n-1} \end{cases}  </cmath>
+Finally, let us list out </math>q_n<math> to find a pattern. Because </math>a_1 = 23<math>, </math>q_1 = 11<math>. Through our recursion, we continue like so:
+<cmath> q_1 = 11, q_2 = 17, q_2 = 20, q_3 = 10, q_4 = 5, q_6 = 14, q_7 = 7, q_8 = 15, q_9 = 19, q_10 = 21, q_11 = 22, q_12 = 11, \dots </cmath>
+Therefore </math>q_n<math> repeats with cycle length </math>11<math>. Since </math>a_{n+1} = a_n<math> if and only iff </math>q_n<math> is even, in each cycle, we have 4 satisfactory values of </math>n<math>. There are </math>\frac{1000 - 10}{11} = 90<math> complete cycles. There are 3 extra values in the last incomplete cycle. Therefore we obtain </math>90 \cdot 4 + 3 = \fbox{363}<math>.
+== Solution 4 (Binary Interpretation, Computer Scientists' Playground) ==
-Now that we know that <math>b_n</math> is unique, we proceed to recast this problem in binary. This is convenient because <math>x \mod{2^n}</math> is simply the last <math>n</math>-bits of <math>x</math> in binary, and if <math>x \equiv 1 \mod{2^n}</math>, it means that of the last <math>n</math> bits of <math>x</math>, only the rightmost bit (henceforth <math>0</math>th bit) is <math>1</math>.
+We first check that </math>\gcd(23, 2^n) = 1<math> hence we are always seeking a unique modular inverse of </math>23<math>, </math>b_n<math>, such that </math>a_n \equiv 23b_n \equiv 1 \mod{2^n}<math>.
+Now that we know that </math>b_n<math> is unique, we proceed to recast this problem in binary. This is convenient because </math>x \mod{2^n}<math> is simply the last </math>n<math>-bits of </math>x<math> in binary, and if </math>x \equiv 1 \mod{2^n}<math>, it means that of the last </math>n<math> bits of </math>x<math>, only the rightmost bit (henceforth </math>0<math>th bit) is </math>1<math>.
 Also, multiplication in binary can be thought of as adding shifted copies of the multiplicand. For example:
@@ Line 93: / Line 120: @@
 </cmath>
-Now note <math>23 = 10111_2</math>, and recall that our objective is to progressively zero out the <math>n</math> leftmost bits of <math>a_n = 10111_2 \times b_n</math> except for the <math>0</math>th bit.
+Now note </math>23 = 10111_2<math>, and recall that our objective is to progressively zero out the </math>n<math> leftmost bits of </math>a_n = 10111_2 \times b_n<math> except for the </math>0<math>th bit.
-Write <math>b_n = \underline{c_{n-1}\cdots c_2c_1c_0}_2</math>, we note that <math>c_0</math> uniquely defines the <math>0</math>th bit of <math>a_n</math>, and once we determine <math>c_0</math>, <math>c_1</math> uniquely determines the <math>1</math>st bit of <math>a_n</math>, so on and so forth.
+Write </math>b_n = \underline{c_{n-1}\cdots c_2c_1c_0}_2<math>, we note that </math>c_0<math> uniquely defines the </math>0<math>th bit of </math>a_n<math>, and once we determine </math>c_0<math>, </math>c_1<math> uniquely determines the </math>1<math>st bit of </math>a_n<math>, so on and so forth.
-For example, <math>c_0 = 1</math> satisfies <math>a_1 \equiv10111_2 \times 1_2 \equiv 1 \mod{10_2}</math>
+For example, </math>c_0 = 1<math> satisfies </math>a_1 \equiv10111_2 \times 1_2 \equiv 1 \mod{10_2}<math>
-Next, we note that the second bit of <math>a_1</math> is <math>1</math>, so we must also have <math>c_1 = 1</math> in order to zero it out, giving
+Next, we note that the second bit of </math>a_1<math> is </math>1<math>, so we must also have </math>c_1 = 1<math> in order to zero it out, giving
 <cmath>a_2 \equiv 10111_2 \times 11_2 \equiv 101110_2 + a_1 \equiv 1000101_2 \equiv 01_2 \mod{100_2}</cmath>
-<math>a_{n+1} = a_{n}</math> happens precisely when <math>c_n = 0</math>. In fact we can see this in action by working out <math>a_3</math>. Note that <math>a_2</math> has 1 on the <math>2</math>nd bit, so we must choose <math>c_2 = 1</math>. This gives
+</math>a_{n+1} = a_{n}<math> happens precisely when </math>c_n = 0<math>. In fact we can see this in action by working out </math>a_3<math>. Note that </math>a_2<math> has 1 on the </math>2<math>nd bit, so we must choose </math>c_2 = 1<math>. This gives
 <cmath>a_3 \equiv 10111_2 \times 111_2 \equiv 1011100_2 + a_2 \equiv 10100001_2 \equiv 001_2 \mod{1000_2}</cmath>
-Note that since the <math>3</math>rd and <math>4</math>th bit are <math>0</math>, <math>c_3 = c_4 = 0</math>, and this gives <math>a_3 = a_4 = a_5</math>.
+Note that since the </math>3<math>rd and </math>4<math>th bit are </math>0<math>, </math>c_3 = c_4 = 0<math>, and this gives </math>a_3 = a_4 = a_5<math>.
-It may seem that this process will take forever, but note that <math>23 = 10111_2</math> has <math>4</math> bits behind the leading digit, and in the worst case, the leading digits of <math>a_n</math> will have a cycle length of at most <math>16</math>. In fact, we find that the cycle length is <math>11</math>, and in the process found that <math>a_3 = a_4 = a_5</math>, <math>a_6 = a_7</math>, and <math>a_{11} = a_{12}</math>.
+It may seem that this process will take forever, but note that </math>23 = 10111_2<math> has </math>4<math> bits behind the leading digit, and in the worst case, the leading digits of </math>a_n<math> will have a cycle length of at most </math>16<math>. In fact, we find that the cycle length is </math>11<math>, and in the process found that </math>a_3 = a_4 = a_5<math>, </math>a_6 = a_7<math>, and </math>a_{11} = a_{12}<math>.
-Since we have <math>90</math> complete cycles of length <math>11</math>, and the last partial cycle yields <math>a_{993} = a_{994} = a_{995}</math> and <math>a_{996} = a_{997}</math>, we have a total of <math>90 \times 4 + 3 = \boxed{363}</math> values of <math>n \le 1000</math> such that <math>a_n = a_{n+1}</math>
+Since we have </math>90<math> complete cycles of length </math>11<math>, and the last partial cycle yields </math>a_{993} = a_{994} = a_{995}<math> and </math>a_{996} = a_{997}<math>, we have a total of </math>90 \times 4 + 3 = \boxed{363}<math> values of </math>n \le 1000<math> such that </math>a_n = a_{n+1}$
 ~ cocoa @ https://www.corgillogical.com

2023 AIME II (Problems • Answer Key • Resources)
Preceded by Problem 14	Followed by Last Problem
1 • 2 • 3 • 4 • 5 • 6 • 7 • 8 • 9 • 10 • 11 • 12 • 13 • 14 • 15
All AIME Problems and Solutions

Page

Toolbox

Search