Difference between revisions of "Talk:1960 IMO Problems/Problem 3"

(A proof of the 3rd question from the 1960 IMO)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
+
  Let ∠ACB be x, and ∠ABC be 90-x. Let M be the midpoint on hypotenuse BC and Q and P be points such that PQ contains BC, and Q is closer to C while P is closer to B. The midpoint will always be in the middle of line QP, unless n is even or infinite, which it is not. Given such a triangle, we can express the altitude to the hypotenuse as a*cos(x)*sin(x). So, h=a*cos(x)*sin(x) We shall now denote line AM by f, where AM is the median to the hypotenuse. This means that line AM= line BM = line CM, and as BM is a/2, f=a/2. ∠MAB is 90-x while ∠MAC is x. This means that ∠AMB=2x and ∠AMC is 180-2x. The length of QP is a/n. Let ∠QAM be k and ∠PAM be z, such that ∠QAP or alpha equals k+z. This means that ∠AQM is 2x-k while ∠APM is 180-2x-z. As M is sin the middle of QP, QM=PM=a/2n. Applying the sine law on triangle AQM, we will find that: 1. sin(k)/(a/2n) = sin(2x-k)/(a/2) 2. 2n*sin(k)/a = 2*sin(2x-k)/a 3. n*sin(k) = sin(2x-k) 4. n*sin(k) = sin(2x)*cos(k)-sin(k)cos(2x) {by sin(a-b) formula} as sin(2x)=2*sin(x)*cos(x), and as h=a*cos(x)*sin(x), 2*sin(x)*cos(x)=2h/a. It follows that cos(2x)=(√(a^2 - 4h^2))/a. 5. n*sin(k)+sin(k)*(√(a^2 - 4h^2))/a)=cos(k)*(2h/a) 6. sin(k)*[n+(√(a^2 - 4h^2))/a)]=cos(k)*(2h/a) 7.tan(k)=2h/(an+√(a^2 - 4h^2)) After doing similarly with tan(z), we can use the tan(z+k) formula to find the value of tan(alpha), as alpha=z+k.
 
 
\section*{Proof for 1960 IMO Problem 3}
 
 
 
Let \( \angle ACB = x \) and \( \angle ABC = 90^\circ - x \).
 
Let \( M \) be the midpoint of the hypotenuse \( BC \), and let \( Q \) and \( P \) be points such that \( PQ \) contains \( BC \), with \( Q \) closer to \( C \) and \( P \) closer to \( B \).
 
Since \( BC \) is divided into \( n \) equal parts, where \( n \) is odd, the length of each segment is:
 
 
 
\[
 
\frac{a}{n}
 
\]
 
 
 
Because \( M \) is the midpoint of \( BC \), it must lie between two consecutive division points, meaning \( M \) is at the center of segment \( QP \).
 
 
 
### Step 1: Altitude to the Hypotenuse 
 
From right triangle trigonometry, the altitude to the hypotenuse is given by:
 
 
 
\[
 
h = a \cos x \sin x
 
\]
 
 
 
### Step 2: Median to the Hypotenuse 
 
Since \( AM \) is the median to the hypotenuse, we have:
 
 
 
\[
 
AM = BM = CM = \frac{a}{2}
 
\]
 
 
 
We also know that:
 
 
 
\[
 
\angle MAB = 90^\circ - x, \quad \angle MAC = x
 
\]
 
\[
 
\angle AMB = 2x, \quad \angle AMC = 180^\circ - 2x
 
\]
 
 
 
### Step 3: Length of \( QP \) and Triangle Relations 
 
The length of \( QP \) is:
 
 
 
\[
 
QP = \frac{a}{n}
 
\]
 
 
 
Define:
 
 
 
\[
 
\angle QAM = k, \quad \angle PAM = z, \quad \angle QAP = \alpha = k + z
 
\]
 
 
 
From angle properties:
 
 
 
\[
 
\angle AQM = 2x - k, \quad \angle APM = 180^\circ - 2x - z
 
\]
 
 
 
Since \( M \) is the midpoint of \( QP \), we have:
 
 
 
\[
 
QM = PM = \frac{a}{2n}
 
\]
 
 
 
### Step 4: Applying the Law of Sines 
 
Applying the sine rule in \( \triangle AQM \):
 
 
 
\[
 
\frac{\sin k}{a/2n} = \frac{\sin(2x - k)}{a/2}
 
\]
 
 
 
Multiplying both sides by \( \frac{2}{a} \):
 
 
 
\[
 
\frac{2n \sin k}{a} = \frac{2 \sin(2x - k)}{a}
 
\]
 
 
 
which simplifies to:
 
 
 
\[
 
n \sin k = \sin(2x - k)
 
\]
 
 
 
Using the identity:
 
 
 
\[
 
\sin(2x - k) = \sin 2x \cos k - \sin k \cos 2x
 
\]
 
 
 
and the double-angle formula:
 
 
 
\[
 
\sin 2x = 2 \sin x \cos x = \frac{2h}{a}
 
\]
 
 
 
we substitute:
 
 
 
\[
 
\cos 2x = \frac{\sqrt{a^2 - 4h^2}}{a}
 
\]
 
 
 
into our equation:
 
 
 
\[
 
n \sin k + \sin k \frac{\sqrt{a^2 - 4h^2}}{a} = \cos k \frac{2h}{a}
 
\]
 
 
 
Factoring:
 
 
 
\[
 
\sin k \left( n + \frac{\sqrt{a^2 - 4h^2}}{a} \right) = \cos k \frac{2h}{a}
 
\]
 
 
 
Dividing both sides by \( \cos k \):
 
 
 
\[
 
\tan k = \frac{2h}{an + \sqrt{a^2 - 4h^2}}
 
\]
 
 
 
### Step 5: Finding \( \tan \alpha \) 
 
Using a similar derivation for \( \tan z \), we apply the tangent sum identity:
 
 
 
\[
 
\tan (z + k) = \frac{\tan z + \tan k}{1 - \tan z \tan k}
 
\]
 
 
 
to find \( \tan \alpha \), where \( \alpha = z + k \).
 

Revision as of 10:32, 5 March 2025

 Let ∠ACB be x, and ∠ABC be 90-x. Let M be the midpoint on hypotenuse BC and Q and P be points such that PQ contains BC, and Q is closer to C while P is closer to B. The midpoint will always be in the middle of line QP, unless n is even or infinite, which it is not. Given such a triangle, we can express the altitude to the hypotenuse as a*cos(x)*sin(x). So, h=a*cos(x)*sin(x) We shall now denote line AM by f, where AM is the median to the hypotenuse. This means that line AM= line BM = line CM, and as BM is a/2, f=a/2. ∠MAB is 90-x while ∠MAC is x. This means that ∠AMB=2x and ∠AMC is 180-2x. The length of QP is a/n. Let ∠QAM be k and ∠PAM be z, such that ∠QAP or alpha equals k+z. This means that ∠AQM is 2x-k while ∠APM is 180-2x-z. As M is sin the middle of QP, QM=PM=a/2n. Applying the sine law on triangle AQM, we will find that: 1. sin(k)/(a/2n) = sin(2x-k)/(a/2) 2. 2n*sin(k)/a = 2*sin(2x-k)/a 3. n*sin(k) = sin(2x-k) 4. n*sin(k) = sin(2x)*cos(k)-sin(k)cos(2x) {by sin(a-b) formula} as sin(2x)=2*sin(x)*cos(x), and as h=a*cos(x)*sin(x), 2*sin(x)*cos(x)=2h/a. It follows that cos(2x)=(√(a^2 - 4h^2))/a. 5. n*sin(k)+sin(k)*(√(a^2 - 4h^2))/a)=cos(k)*(2h/a) 6. sin(k)*[n+(√(a^2 - 4h^2))/a)]=cos(k)*(2h/a) 7.tan(k)=2h/(an+√(a^2 - 4h^2)) After doing similarly with tan(z), we can use the tan(z+k) formula to find the value of tan(alpha), as alpha=z+k.